Flavors & Fillings
Custom Cake Flavors & Fillings
We offer 19 signature cake flavors and 9 fillings, all included at our base price, with more options than any competitor and no premium upcharge. Every cake is made from scratch with our house-made buttercream.
Indianapolis's most-awarded cake bakery
1,500+ five-star reviews on 
Signature Cake Flavors & Fillings
Your cake includes one signature flavor and one filling per tier. Opt out of a filling and we use our homemade vanilla buttercream between the layers.
19 Cake Flavorsall included at base price, no upcharge
- Butter Pecan
- Almond
- Banana
- Carrot Cake
- Cherry Chip
- Chocolate
- Chocolate Mint
- Confetti
- Cookie Doughcake pops only
- Lemon
- Marblecake only
- Orange
- Pineapple
- Raspberry
- Red Velvet
- Spice
- Strawberry
- Vanilla
- Whitecake only
9 Signature Fillings
- Creamy Caramel
- Chocolate Mousse
- Cheesecake Mousse
- Cookies n Cream Mousse
- White Chocolate Mousse
- Strawberry Mousse
- Strawberry Preserves
- Raspberry Preserves
- Orange Preserves
Gluten-free available in Yellow, Confetti, and Chocolate. We cannot combine gluten-free and vegan in the same cake.
Crowd-Favorite Pairings
Not sure what goes together? Here is where we would start.
Butter Pecan + Creamy Caramel
Our fan favorite. Customers call this combination to die for.
Confetti + Cookies n Cream Mousse
A fun birthday classic that crowds love.
Red Velvet + Cheesecake Mousse
A rich, grown-up favorite.
What Our Customers Say
The cupcakes are so good because you get to try multiple flavors, the strawberry, vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, and dulce de leche are all amazing.
Megan Verified on Vanilla cake with strawberry mousse, and it was a hit. My best cake experience yet, quick response and very professional.
Dalaizha C. Verified on My son asked for a Lego cake and they made it happen. The cake was super delicious and did not disappoint. I will be returning for every occasion.
Sheila G. Verified on 
Taste Them for Yourself
Book a $30 tasting and try three flavors and three fillings in any combination. The fee applies to your order when you book.